REITs vs. Real Estate Crowdfunding
Jerry Chu
Want to invest in real estate but not sure where to start? REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) and real estate crowdfunding are two popular options that make property investing accessible without requiring you to own or manage properties directly. Here's a quick breakdown:
- REITs: You buy shares in a company that owns and operates income-generating properties. They're traded like stocks, offering high liquidity and steady dividends (average yield ~5%). Minimum investment is often under $100.
- Real Estate Crowdfunding: You invest in fractional real estate projects through online platforms. Potential returns are higher (11-15%+), but funds are tied up for 3–10 years, and minimum investments range from $500 to $25,000+.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | REITs | Real Estate Crowdfunding |
|---|---|---|
| Liquidity | High (tradable daily) | Low (3–10 year lock-up) |
| Minimum Investment | ~$100 | $500–$50,000+ |
| Returns | ~12–13% (historical) | ~11–15%+ (projected) |
| Diversification | High (broad portfolio) | Low (single property focus) |
| Risk | Market volatility | Property-specific risks |
Key takeaway: Choose REITs for simplicity, liquidity, and steady income. Opt for crowdfunding if you're willing to take on higher risks for potentially higher returns and want more control over your investments.
REITs vs Real Estate Crowdfunding: Complete Investment Comparison
REITs vs. Real Estate Crowdfunding
sbb-itb-a24235f
Investment Structure Differences
REITs and real estate crowdfunding platforms handle investments in distinct ways, which plays a big role in determining which option might suit your portfolio better.
How REITs Work
A REIT, or Real Estate Investment Trust, is essentially a company or trust that owns and operates income-generating properties. When you invest in a REIT, you’re essentially buying stock in that company, which means you’re indirectly investing in the properties it owns.
"A REIT is a specialized type of real estate investment company that is formed specifically for the purpose of acquiring and managing commercial real estate assets." – FNRP Editor, First National Realty Partners
Think of REITs as a way to access a broad portfolio of properties without owning any directly. For example, Prologis, a leading publicly traded REIT, specializes in industrial and warehouse spaces. By purchasing shares in Prologis, you gain exposure to a diversified portfolio of such properties across various markets.
One of the standout features of REITs is their professional management. Decisions about buying, selling, or managing properties are handled by experienced teams. Additionally, REITs are legally required to distribute at least 90% of their taxable income as dividends to shareholders. This rule, established when Congress created REITs in 1960, ensures that investors receive steady income based on the REIT’s performance.
How Real Estate Crowdfunding Works
Real estate crowdfunding offers a more hands-on and targeted approach. Instead of investing in a large portfolio, you join forces with other investors to fund specific properties or projects.
"Real Estate Crowdfunding Platforms source investment capital through web-based offerings that pool investment capital from 'crowds' of individual investors who want to gain exposure to commercial real estate assets." – FNRP Editor, First National Realty Partners
Here’s how it works: A sponsor identifies a property, such as a 20-unit apartment complex in Austin, Texas, and sets up a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) - usually an LLC or limited liability partnership - to own that property. When you invest, you’re buying a fractional share in that SPV, making you a partial owner of the specific property. Your returns are directly tied to how well that property performs.
Crowdfunding gives investors more control over their choices. You can evaluate the sponsor’s track record, the property’s location, and the overall business plan before deciding where to put your money. Platforms like Lofty (https://lofty.ai) make this even easier by allowing investors to purchase fractions of rental properties across the U.S. and earn rental income directly. You can even sell whenever you’d like instantly through their secondary market, just like with publicly traded REITs.
Unlike REITs, crowdfunding investments don’t come with any legal requirement to distribute income. Returns are entirely dependent on the project’s structure and performance, so the sponsor’s expertise is critical. This makes doing your homework on the sponsor and the property a must.
This breakdown of investment structures lays the groundwork for exploring liquidity, accessibility, and risk in the next section.
Liquidity and Accessibility Comparison
When deciding between REITs and real estate crowdfunding, it's important to weigh liquidity alongside potential returns.
REIT Liquidity
Publicly traded REITs function similarly to stocks. They’re listed on major exchanges, allowing investors to buy or sell shares almost instantly during market hours.
"Selling REITs takes the click of a button, no FOR SALE sign required." – SoFi
Real Estate Crowdfunding Liquidity
On the other hand, real estate crowdfunding investments are far less liquid. When you commit funds to a crowdfunded property, your money is typically tied up for 3 to 10 years, depending on the project's timeline or when the property is sold.
"An investment in a crowdfunded real estate deal typically requires a funding commitment of 5-10 years, during which time the interest in the property cannot be sold." – First National Realty Partners
Exiting early is uncommon, and when allowed, it often comes with penalties. This lack of liquidity also poses added risks, especially if the platform ceases operations.
Accessibility for Fractional Investors
When it comes to accessibility, REITs have a clear advantage. You can start investing with the cost of a single share - often less than $100. Many brokers even support fractional shares, making it easy for anyone with a brokerage account to get started.
Real estate crowdfunding platforms, such as Lofty (https://lofty.ai), offer entry points as low as $20, but others may require anywhere from $500 to over $50,000. However, many of these platforms limit participation to accredited investors - defined as individuals with a net worth over $1 million (excluding their primary residence) or an annual income exceeding $200,000 (or $300,000 jointly with a spouse). Even platforms offering Regulation Crowdfunding (Reg CF) for non-accredited investors impose strict annual investment limits if your income or net worth is below $124,000.
| Liquidity & Accessibility Summary | Publicly Traded REITs | Real Estate Crowdfunding |
|---|---|---|
| Liquidity | High; tradable daily on exchanges | Low; 3–10 year lockup periods |
| Ease of Exit | Sell shares instantly at market price | Difficult; typically tied to project completion |
| Minimum Investment | Price of one share (often under $100) | $100 to $50,000+ |
| Investor Requirements | Open to all retail investors | Often restricted to accredited investors |
| Transaction Costs | Minimal (standard brokerage fees) | Higher due to platform and management fees |
Returns, Income, and Risk Factors
This section breaks down how returns, income, and risk differ between REITs and real estate crowdfunding, expanding on the earlier discussion about structure and liquidity.
REIT Returns and Dividends
REITs are legally required to distribute at least 90% of their taxable income as dividends. This results in an average dividend yield of about 5%, with historical total returns - factoring in both dividends and share price growth - hovering around 12–13%. Their broad portfolios, which often include dozens or even hundreds of properties, help reduce the impact of any single property underperforming.
Real Estate Crowdfunding Returns
Real estate crowdfunding generally aims for higher returns, often targeting annual yields between 11–15% or more. Some aggressive deals even project returns exceeding 300%. However, typical quarterly distributions fall between 5% and 11%, with long-term returns averaging around 9.6% or higher.
These deals often operate under a waterfall model, which prioritizes a 6–8% preferred return for investors. Once that threshold is met, profits are split with the sponsor. However, returns can vary significantly, as they depend heavily on the performance of individual properties and the expertise of the sponsor.
Platforms like Lofty provide fractional real estate investment opportunities that align with this model. These platforms offer curated rental properties, giving investors transparent insights into potential risks and returns.
Risk Comparison
While the returns differ, the risk profiles of REITs and real estate crowdfunding also vary considerably.
REITs are exposed to market volatility. For example, rising interest rates can hurt share prices and drive up borrowing costs. On the other hand, crowdfunding investments carry property-specific risks, such as extended vacancies, delays in construction, or unfavorable local market trends. Since crowdfunding deals often involve single properties, these risks can have a more pronounced impact on returns. Additionally, these investments are typically illiquid, with funds often locked up for 5–10 years.
The table below highlights the key risk factors for each model:
| Risk Factor | REITs | Real Estate Crowdfunding |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Risk Type | Market volatility and interest rates | Property-specific and sponsor-related |
| Diversification | High (broad portfolio) | Low (single property focus) |
| Income Stability | High (mandated dividends) | Variable (project-dependent) |
| Typical Annual Return | ~12–13% (historical total) | ~11–15%+ (projected) |
| Tax Treatment | Dividends taxed as ordinary income | Varies (interest, dividends, or capital gains) |
Pros and Cons of Each Investment Type
When it comes to deciding between REITs and real estate crowdfunding, understanding their unique strengths and weaknesses is essential. Each option serves different investor preferences, depending on factors like risk tolerance, financial goals, and investment timeframe.
REIT Pros and Cons
REITs stand out for their liquidity and diversification, making them a popular choice for many investors.
On the plus side, REITs are highly accessible and easy to trade, much like stocks. They provide broad exposure to a variety of properties, which helps mitigate the risk of any single asset underperforming. On average, REITs deliver a dividend yield of about 5%, offering a reliable income stream.
However, they’re not without downsides. REIT share prices often mirror the ups and downs of the stock market, introducing volatility even if the underlying properties remain stable. Rising interest rates can also hurt share prices and increase borrowing costs. Additionally, investors have no say in which properties are bought or managed - those decisions are handled by the REIT’s management team. Another drawback is taxation: REIT dividends are considered ordinary income, which could mean rates as high as 37%, plus an extra 3.8% surtax.
Real Estate Crowdfunding Pros and Cons
Real estate crowdfunding is appealing for those looking for higher returns and a more hands-on approach to property selection.
In equity deals, annualized returns can range from 18% to 25%, while debt deals typically yield between 8% and 12%. This model allows investors to dive deep into asset details and business strategies, enabling thorough due diligence before committing funds. Additionally, these investments often have a lower correlation with stock market movements, which can provide some stability during economic downturns. Some deals also offer tax perks, such as depreciation deductions.
That said, there are trade-offs. Crowdfunding investments often require long lock-up periods, meaning your money isn’t easily accessible. Minimum investment amounts vary widely across platforms. Concentration risk is another concern - many deals focus on a single property, so poor performance on one project could lead to significant losses. Furthermore, higher-return opportunities are often available only to accredited investors who meet strict income or net worth criteria. Lastly, platforms typically charge annual management fees of 1–2%.
Platforms like Lofty aim to simplify fractional real estate investing by offering transparency and accessibility, making it easier to get started without needing large sums of capital or specialized knowledge.
Comparison Table: REITs vs. Real Estate Crowdfunding
| Feature | REITs | Real Estate Crowdfunding |
|---|---|---|
| Diversification | High (broad portfolio of assets) | Low (usually focuses on a single property) |
| Control Over Assets | None (decisions made by REIT managers) | High (investors choose specific projects) |
| Potential Returns | Moderate (steady dividends, modest growth) | High (18–25% for equity; 8–12% for debt) |
| Primary Risks | Market volatility, interest rate sensitivity | Project failure, platform risk |
| Tax Treatment | Dividends taxed as ordinary income | Varies (capital gains, depreciation benefits) |
| Best For | Passive, income-focused investors | Long-term investors comfortable with illiquidity |
Choosing the Right Option for Your Investment Goals
When deciding between REITs and real estate crowdfunding, consider factors like liquidity, investment size, and your timeline.
Publicly traded REITs are a great choice if you value liquidity. You can buy and sell shares just like stocks, making it easy to access your money when needed. Plus, they often require minimal capital - sometimes less than $100 - making them an attractive option for those looking for steady dividend income. However, they come with exposure to market fluctuations and interest rate changes, which can impact returns.
On the other hand, real estate crowdfunding is better suited for long-term investors who are comfortable locking up their capital for 5 to 10 years. The minimum investment can vary widely, with many platforms starting at $25,000 to $50,000, though some offer entry points as low as $500. Crowdfunding can offer higher potential returns, with equity deals yielding 18–25% and debt deals providing 8–12%. However, this approach focuses on individual projects, which means less diversification and higher risk if a project underperforms.
For those seeking a middle ground, platforms like Lofty provide an opportunity to diversify across rental properties with lower capital requirements and shorter lock-up periods. This can be a practical way to balance risk and liquidity while staying aligned with broader market trends.
FAQs
What’s the difference between REITs and real estate crowdfunding?
REITs and real estate crowdfunding both let you invest in real estate without the hassle of owning property directly, but they come with distinct differences in how they work, their accessibility, and the risks involved.
REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) are publicly traded companies that manage portfolios of diversified properties. You can buy and sell REIT shares on stock exchanges, making them a highly liquid investment. They tend to provide consistent dividends and are generally considered lower-risk options for those seeking steady returns.
Real estate crowdfunding, on the other hand, involves investing in individual properties or projects through private platforms. While this approach offers less liquidity, it gives you more control over specific investments. Crowdfunding can potentially deliver higher returns, but it comes with increased risks, such as delays in projects or market fluctuations.
Platforms like Lofty make crowdfunding easier to access by letting investors buy fractional shares of rental properties across the U.S. This means you can earn rental income and benefit from property appreciation without needing a large upfront investment or dealing with property management headaches.
Deciding between REITs and crowdfunding comes down to your investment style: do you value the stability and convenience of REITs, or are you drawn to the more hands-on, targeted opportunities of crowdfunding? The choice is yours.
What are the differences in liquidity and risk between REITs and real estate crowdfunding?
REITs and real estate crowdfunding have distinct differences, particularly in liquidity and risk. Publicly traded REITs are traded on stock exchanges, allowing investors to buy or sell shares during regular trading hours, with transactions typically settling within two business days. This makes them as liquid as most stocks. On the other hand, real estate crowdfunding investments are often tied to specific projects, which can last anywhere from 3 to 10 years. Exiting early is usually tricky and might only be possible through a limited secondary market - if one even exists.
When it comes to risk, REITs tend to spread their investments across a diversified portfolio of properties and are regulated by the SEC. This setup reduces the risk tied to individual properties and provides more stable and predictable dividend payouts. Crowdfunding investments, however, often focus on a single property or a small group of properties. This narrower focus makes them more susceptible to risks like construction delays or leasing issues. While the potential for higher returns exists, so does the likelihood of losses.
For those interested in owning fractional shares of individual rental properties, platforms like Lofty make it possible to invest without needing a large upfront payment. However, these investments still come with the same liquidity and risk challenges typical of real estate crowdfunding.
What should I consider when deciding between REITs and real estate crowdfunding?
When choosing between REITs and real estate crowdfunding, it’s essential to weigh your goals and how hands-on you want to be. REITs are traded on public stock exchanges, meaning you can buy or sell shares during market hours, giving you high liquidity. In contrast, crowdfunding often involves committing to specific properties for the long term. While this approach provides more transparency and a sense of control, it limits your ability to quickly access your funds.
Next, think about the investment amount and potential returns. REITs are accessible with a relatively small upfront investment, making them a great option if you’re starting small. Crowdfunding, however, usually requires a larger initial commitment but might offer higher returns thanks to lower fees and the perks of direct ownership. With REITs, you get diversification and steady income through mandatory dividend payouts. Crowdfunding, on the other hand, can be more unpredictable but lets you focus on individual properties, like rental homes, which could lead to higher rewards.
Lastly, consider tax benefits and your comfort with risk. REITs are tightly regulated, offering tax advantages and providing a more passive way to earn steady income. Crowdfunding, though, gives a more direct sense of property ownership and could align incentives between investors and property managers. That said, it often comes with higher risks and longer holding periods. Platforms like Lofty make it easier to invest in rental properties through fractional ownership, blending accessibility with the perks of owning real estate directly.
Related Blog Posts
