REITs for Beginners: Pros and Cons Explained
Jerry Chu
Want to invest in real estate without buying property? REITs can be a simple and accessible option.
Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) let you invest in income-generating properties like malls, apartments, and warehouses through shares, offering a hands-off way to earn dividends and diversify your portfolio. They’re professionally managed, trade like stocks, and require much less upfront capital than owning property directly.
Key Points:
- What REITs Are: Companies that own or finance real estate, distributing 90% of taxable income as dividends.
- Types: Equity REITs (rent-focused), mortgage REITs (loan-focused), hybrid REITs (combination).
- Benefits: Low entry cost, diversification, passive income, liquidity, professional management.
- Risks: Limited growth, higher dividend taxes, market volatility, interest rate sensitivity, sector-specific challenges.
REITs are ideal for passive income seekers and those looking to diversify without the hassles of property ownership. But they may not suit investors focused on long-term growth or control over investments.
REITs Pros and Cons Comparison Chart for Investors
How REITs Work: Types, Mechanics, and Earnings
Types of REITs
REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) come in different forms based on what they invest in and how investors can access them. Equity REITs focus on owning and managing income-producing properties, earning from rents and property appreciation. On the other hand, mortgage REITs (mREITs) generate income by investing in real estate loans and mortgage-backed securities, profiting primarily from interest payments. Hybrid REITs combine both strategies, earning from rents, interest, and potential sales of properties or loans.
REITs also vary in how they’re traded. Publicly traded REITs are listed on major stock exchanges like the NYSE or Nasdaq. You can buy and sell them just like stocks, and they’re required to file detailed reports with the SEC, making them easy to trade and well-regulated. Public non-traded REITs, while registered with the SEC, don’t trade on public exchanges. These are sold through brokers, often come with higher upfront fees, and might have restrictions on when you can sell your shares. Lastly, private REITs are typically available only to accredited or institutional investors. These aren’t SEC-registered or publicly traded, and they offer limited liquidity, making them less suitable for everyday investors.
Knowing the different types of REITs helps investors understand how they operate and generate returns.
How REITs Generate Income
REITs are required by law to distribute at least 90% of their taxable income to shareholders as dividends. This rule leads to regular and often higher dividends compared to typical corporations. For equity REITs, rental income from tenants covers expenses like maintenance, taxes, insurance, and loan payments. Whatever remains - often measured by a metric called Funds From Operations (FFO) - is paid out as dividends. These dividends are deposited directly into your brokerage account, where you can reinvest them through a dividend reinvestment plan (DRIP) or use them as passive income.
Investors benefit from REITs in two primary ways: dividends and share price growth. For example, a publicly traded equity REIT that owns apartment buildings might offer an annual dividend yield of 4%–6%, funded by rental income. At the same time, the share price could rise if property values and rental rates go up. Mortgage REITs, on the other hand, might offer higher dividend yields, around 8%–10%, as they rely on interest income. However, their share prices can be more sensitive to changes in interest rates. Since REITs distribute most of their earnings, they often rely on debt or issuing new shares to finance growth, which can limit their long-term expansion compared to companies that reinvest a larger portion of their profits.
Understanding these income streams is key to evaluating REITs, but taxes play a big role in how much investors ultimately keep.
Tax Treatment of REIT Investments
Taxes on REIT dividends depend on the type of account you hold them in. In a taxable brokerage account, most REIT dividends are taxed as ordinary income at your marginal tax rate, which is higher than the rate for long-term capital gains. However, some portions of REIT distributions might qualify as qualified dividends (taxed at lower rates) or return of capital (ROC). ROC isn’t taxed immediately but instead reduces your cost basis, which could increase capital gains taxes when you eventually sell the shares.
The tax situation changes with retirement accounts. In a traditional IRA or 401(k), REIT dividends and capital gains grow tax-deferred - you won’t pay taxes yearly, but withdrawals in retirement will be taxed as ordinary income. In a Roth IRA, qualified withdrawals are tax-free, meaning REIT dividends and growth escape taxes entirely if you follow the rules. Because of this, many U.S. investors prefer holding high-dividend REITs in tax-advantaged accounts to avoid the annual tax hit, while using taxable accounts for investments that benefit from lower capital gains rates or qualified dividends.
Advantages of Investing in REITs
Low Entry Costs
Investing in REITs makes entering the real estate market much more accessible compared to buying property outright. Instead of needing a hefty down payment - like $40,000 for a $200,000 property - REITs allow you to start with the price of a single share, often under $100. Some brokerages even let you buy fractional shares, lowering the barrier further. For instance, the Vanguard Real Estate ETF (VNQ) typically trades between $80 and $100 per share, giving you exposure to a range of REITs across sectors. This affordability has made real estate investing more mainstream, with over 87 million Americans now owning REIT shares directly or through mutual funds and retirement accounts.
Diversification Across Properties and Locations
REITs provide an easy way to spread your investment across a variety of properties and locations, reducing the risks tied to putting all your money into a single property. By law, REITs must allocate at least 75% of their assets to real estate, and many focus on specific sectors such as apartments, industrial spaces, healthcare facilities, or retail properties. REIT ETFs take this a step further by holding dozens or even hundreds of individual REITs. With just one investment, you can gain exposure to properties all over the U.S. - from apartment complexes in Texas to logistics hubs in California and medical offices in Florida - without needing deep pockets or specialized expertise.
Passive Income Through Dividends
REITs are required to distribute a significant portion of their income as dividends, offering investors a reliable source of passive income. Unlike owning rental properties, where you’d be responsible for property management, REIT investors can enjoy income without lifting a finger. Dividends are typically paid quarterly and deposited directly into your brokerage account. Historically, REITs have delivered higher average dividend yields than the S&P 500, making them particularly appealing to income-focused investors.
Liquidity and Ease of Trading
One of the biggest advantages of publicly traded REITs is their liquidity. Unlike physical properties, which can take weeks or months to sell, REIT shares can be bought or sold instantly during market hours through any brokerage account. With over 150 REITs listed on major U.S. exchanges like the NYSE and Nasdaq, you can adjust your portfolio quickly if your financial needs change or if you want to rebalance your investments. This flexibility is a major benefit compared to the lengthy process of selling a rental property.
Professional Management
REITs are managed by seasoned professionals who handle everything from acquiring properties to managing tenants. For investors, this means you can tap into lucrative real estate sectors - like data centers, healthcare facilities, or industrial warehouses - without needing to become a real estate expert yourself. These management teams ensure efficient operations and aim to maximize returns, making REITs an attractive option for beginners and experienced investors alike. With REITs, you get the benefits of commercial real estate without the headaches of direct property ownership.
REIT Investing Explained: Pros, Cons & Why This Year Could Be a Game-Changer
sbb-itb-a24235f
Disadvantages and Risks of REITs
While REITs come with appealing benefits, they also carry certain risks that investors should carefully weigh.
Limited Growth Due to High Dividend Payouts
REITs are required to distribute a large portion of their earnings as dividends. While this ensures steady income for investors, it leaves little room for reinvestment. Without significant retained earnings, REITs have limited capacity to acquire new properties or expand their portfolios. In contrast, traditional companies often reinvest profits to fuel growth. For investors prioritizing capital appreciation over income, this can be a drawback, as it restricts the potential for long-term growth.
Higher Tax Rates on Dividends
One of the less appealing aspects of REIT dividends is their tax treatment. Unlike qualified dividends, which are taxed at rates ranging from 0-20%, REIT dividends are typically taxed as ordinary income. This means federal tax rates could climb as high as 37% by 2025. For those in higher tax brackets, this can significantly reduce the actual return on investment. While some investors may qualify for the 20% QBI (Qualified Business Income) deduction under Section 199A, it’s important to consult a tax advisor to see if this applies to your specific situation.
Market Volatility and Interest Rate Sensitivity
Publicly traded REITs often mirror the behavior of stocks, which makes them prone to market volatility. For example, during the 2020 market downturn, many REITs lost over 50% of their value, with recovery varying widely by sector. Additionally, REITs are highly sensitive to interest rate changes. When the Federal Reserve raised rates in 2022, the FTSE Nareit All Equity REITs Index dropped roughly 25%. Rising rates increase borrowing costs for REITs, which frequently rely on debt to finance their operations, and make bonds more attractive to income-focused investors. These factors can put significant downward pressure on REIT prices, adding to the risks tied to sector-specific performance.
Sector-Specific Risks
Not all REITs are created equal, and their performance often hinges on the sectors they focus on. For instance, retail REITs have been hit hard by the rise of e-commerce and the closure of brick-and-mortar stores. Similarly, office REITs have struggled with the shift to remote work, with vacancy rates in major cities like New York exceeding 20% after 2020. Investing in a REIT tied to a struggling sector can lead to poor returns, even if the broader real estate market is performing well.
No Direct Control Over Investments
Investing in REITs means handing over decision-making to professional management teams. While this hands-off approach may be convenient, it also has its downsides. Investors have no say in selecting properties, choosing tenants, or making operational decisions. If management makes poor choices, the performance of your investment could suffer. Unlike owning real estate directly, where you have control over key aspects, REITs require you to trust that the management team will act in the best interest of shareholders. This lack of control is a trade-off that comes with the convenience of REIT investing.
Are REITs Right for Your Investment Strategy?
Matching REITs to Your Investment Goals
Before diving into REITs, it's crucial to align them with your investment goals. If you're seeking consistent passive income, REITs can be a great option. By law, they must distribute at least 90% of their taxable income as dividends, which translates to regular cash payments.
However, if your primary focus is long-term growth, REITs may not be the ideal choice. Since they distribute most of their earnings, they have limited funds for reinvestment, which can hinder significant long-term appreciation. REITs are most effective for those looking for a balanced strategy - providing steady income now, potential property value appreciation over time, and real estate diversification to complement a portfolio dominated by stocks and bonds.
Questions to Ask Before Investing
To avoid surprises down the road, consider these key questions before investing in REITs. First, evaluate your risk tolerance: Are you comfortable with market fluctuations? Since REITs trade like stocks, they can be volatile, especially during interest rate hikes or economic downturns. Next, think about your time horizon. REITs are not ideal for short-term needs. A longer investment period allows you to weather market ups and downs while collecting dividends.
Decide whether your priority is income or growth. Keep in mind the tax implications - REIT dividends are taxed at higher federal rates, up to 37%, but holding REITs in an IRA or another tax-advantaged account can help reduce this burden. Lastly, ask yourself if you're okay with having no direct control over property decisions. REIT managers handle buying and selling properties, leaving you with little say in the process.
For those who prefer more control, alternative investment models like fractional ownership might be worth exploring.
Fractional Real Estate Alternatives Like Lofty
If you want to invest in real estate but prefer more control over specific properties, platforms like Lofty offer a compelling alternative. Lofty allows you to purchase fractional shares of U.S. rental properties with a minimum investment of just $50 - no hefty down payment required. You’ll earn daily rental income (unlike the quarterly payouts typical of REITs) and can diversify across 150 properties in 40 markets without the hassle of managing tenants or property maintenance.
Lofty works well alongside REITs in a diversified portfolio. Use REITs for broad exposure to commercial sectors like office buildings or malls, and pair them with Lofty to own fractions of specific rental properties you can personally evaluate. Lofty also offers transparency into individual properties and allows you to sell your holdings instantly through its marketplace. This blend of REIT convenience and direct property selection provides a flexible way to combine broad market exposure with hands-on real estate investing.
Getting Started as a First-Time Investor
Once you've clarified your investment goals, here's how to take the first step. If REITs appeal to you, consider starting with a REIT ETF like the Vanguard REIT ETF, which spreads risk across various property types and companies. Financial experts often recommend allocating 5-15% of your portfolio to REITs to avoid overexposure to a single asset class. Use tools like the SEC's EDGAR database to review REIT filings and analyze metrics such as funds from operations (FFO) and payout ratios.
If fractional ownership feels like a better fit, explore platforms like Lofty to research property performance and daily income potential. Take time to understand the platform's risks, and consult a tax advisor to plan for potential tax implications. A thoughtful approach - combining income, growth, and diversification - can help you align your investments with your financial goals, risk tolerance, and tax situation. Start small, stay informed, and build your portfolio carefully.
Conclusion: Weighing the Pros and Cons of REITs
REITs offer a straightforward way to invest in real estate without the challenges of owning property directly. With over 87 million Americans holding REIT shares, it's clear that this investment option resonates with many. They combine the liquidity of stocks with consistent income payouts, but their required high dividend distributions can limit growth opportunities. Plus, dividends are taxed as ordinary income, with rates potentially reaching as high as 37%. Market fluctuations and rising interest rates have also impacted returns, resulting in a decrease of about 25% from 2022 to 2023.
When considering REITs, it’s crucial to align them with your financial goals. If steady income and diversification are priorities, many experts suggest dedicating a portion of your portfolio to REITs. Options like REIT ETFs, such as the Vanguard REIT ETF, provide instant diversification and can be included in tax-advantaged accounts like IRAs to help manage tax obligations. To evaluate dividend reliability, focus on metrics like Funds From Operations (FFO) and dividend yield, which you can find through resources like the SEC's EDGAR database.
For those wanting more control over their real estate investments, fractional ownership platforms like Lofty offer an appealing alternative. With an entry point as low as $50, Lofty provides daily rental income, access to 150 properties across 40 markets, and the ability to sell holdings instantly. By combining the broad market exposure of REITs with the targeted property selection available on platforms like Lofty, you can create a real estate strategy that matches your risk tolerance and financial plans.
Start small, stay informed, and ensure your investments align with what you’re aiming to achieve.
FAQs
What are the risks and returns of investing in REITs compared to traditional real estate?
Investing in REITs offers a way to tap into the real estate market with less risk and greater liquidity. Unlike directly owning property, REITs let you spread your investment across multiple assets, reducing exposure to individual market swings. However, the trade-off is that returns from REITs tend to be more modest compared to traditional real estate investments, which, while potentially more profitable, come with higher risks like market volatility and the demands of property management.
For those new to investing or looking for a hands-off option, REITs provide an accessible entry point into real estate without the hefty upfront costs or the day-to-day responsibilities that come with owning property.
What are the tax differences between holding REITs in a taxable account and a retirement account?
When you hold REITs in a taxable account, the dividends are usually taxed as ordinary income, which could lead to a higher tax bill depending on your income bracket. On top of that, if you sell REIT shares for a profit, those gains might be hit with capital gains taxes.
On the flip side, keeping REITs in a retirement account, like a traditional IRA or 401(k), lets your investment grow tax-deferred until you start withdrawing funds. And if you opt for a Roth IRA, qualified withdrawals are tax-free - meaning you won’t owe taxes on dividends or any gains at all. This tax advantage can make retirement accounts an appealing way to boost the returns on your REIT investments.
What should I look for when evaluating a REIT before investing?
When looking into a REIT, pay close attention to its past performance, the range and caliber of its property holdings, and the track record of its management team. Dive into its financial statements to ensure steady income streams and reasonable debt levels. Additionally, independent reports and current market trends can offer helpful context.
Platforms like Lofty provide access to in-depth property information and projected returns, giving you the tools to evaluate investment opportunities with greater clarity.
Related Blog Posts
