REIT Allocation Strategies for Investors
Jerry Chu
Looking to invest in real estate without buying the entire property? You have two main options: REITs or fractional real estate platforms.
- REITs are publicly traded funds that let you invest in diverse real estate portfolios like offices, malls, and apartments. They’re easy to buy, offer steady dividends (90% of taxable income is paid out), and are highly liquid since they trade like stocks.
- Fractional platforms like Lofty allow you to buy shares in specific rental properties. You earn daily rental income and can pick properties to suit your preferences, but liquidity depends on demand within the platform.
Which is better? It depends on your goals. REITs are hands-off, while fractional platforms give you more control but require active involvement. Many investors combine both for income and diversification.
| Feature | REITs | Fractional Platforms |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | Buy via brokerage | Fully digital process |
| Diversification | Broad property exposure | Choose specific properties |
| Income | Quarterly dividends | Daily rental payments |
| Liquidity | High (trades like stocks) | Moderate (platform-dependent) |
| Control | Minimal | High (property selection) |
Tip: Start small with both to balance growth and stability.
How Do I Diversify My REIT Portfolio? - Learn About Economics
1. Traditional REIT Investments
Traditional REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) offer several benefits, including ease of access, portfolio diversification, balanced risk management, and liquidity. These publicly traded firms own income-generating real estate assets and have become increasingly popular among financial advisors. In fact, research from NMG Consulting reveals that 4 out of 5 advisors now include REITs in their clients' portfolios, primarily for their diversification benefits.
Accessibility
One of the biggest advantages of traditional REITs is their accessibility. Unlike purchasing rental properties - which often requires hefty down payments, credit checks, and property management expertise - REITs are as easy to buy as stocks. You can purchase them through any standard brokerage account.
What’s more, a single REIT investment provides exposure to a diverse portfolio of properties. These portfolios may include assets across various locations, property types, and business districts - something that would be nearly impossible to replicate through direct ownership.
Portfolio Diversification
REITs are particularly valuable for diversification because they operate on a different economic cycle than stocks and bonds. While the stock market typically follows a 6- to 7-year cycle, real estate cycles tend to last a decade or more. Kevin Weigel, Portfolio Strategist at U.S. Bank Wealth Management, explains:
Equity REITs can be a good diversifier to a normal equity portfolio, and mortgage-backed REITs can be a good way to diversify a traditional bond portfolio.
Additionally, studies show that REITs have a low-to-moderate correlation with other asset classes. This means their performance often moves in the opposite direction of stocks and bonds, helping to reduce overall portfolio volatility. REITs also hold a mix of property types - residential, commercial, industrial, and healthcare - which further enhances diversification and earnings stability.
Risk-Adjusted Returns
Traditional REITs offer a balanced approach to risk and reward, making them a reliable option during periods of market uncertainty. The tangible real estate assets underlying REITs help stabilize returns, even when stock markets fluctuate.
Another key feature is their mandatory dividend structure. REITs are required to distribute at least 90% of their taxable income as dividends. This creates a steady income stream that is less influenced by market sentiment compared to regular stock dividends. At the same time, REITs still offer growth potential through property value appreciation and increasing rental income.
Liquidity
Liquidity is another standout feature of traditional REITs. Unlike direct property ownership - which can take weeks or months to sell - REIT shares trade on major stock exchanges and can be bought or sold instantly during market hours. This allows investors to make quick portfolio adjustments in response to market conditions or personal financial needs.
The ability to quickly access funds or rebalance a portfolio gives REITs a significant advantage over direct real estate investments. Combined with their risk-return profile, this liquidity makes traditional REITs a flexible and practical choice for many investors.
2. Fractional Real Estate Platforms (e.g., Lofty)
Fractional real estate platforms provide an alternative to traditional REIT investments, offering a middle ground between REITs and direct property ownership. These platforms, like Lofty, allow investors to purchase shares in individual rental properties, making it easier to enter the U.S. rental market with a smaller financial commitment and less expertise. Here's how these platforms stack up against traditional REITs in terms of accessibility, diversification, returns, and liquidity.
Accessibility
Fractional platforms make real estate investing more accessible by lowering the financial and logistical barriers. With smaller minimum investments and entirely digital transactions, they eliminate the complexities of managing properties directly. Investors can explore properties online, review financial details, and complete purchases quickly - streamlining a process that’s typically more time-consuming in traditional real estate deals.
Portfolio Diversification
One of the standout features of fractional platforms is the ability to diversify across specific markets. Instead of investing in a REIT that pools numerous properties, investors can handpick properties in different cities or neighborhoods. This targeted approach allows for a strategic distribution of risk, as investors can balance their portfolios across various rental markets and local economic conditions - something traditional REITs don’t usually offer.
Risk-Adjusted Returns
Returns in fractional investments are tied directly to the performance of individual properties, such as occupancy rates, rental income, and local market trends. Platforms like Lofty even distribute rental income daily, offering a more frequent cash flow compared to the quarterly dividends typical of REITs. This combination of regular income and potential property appreciation creates a unique risk-return balance that might appeal to those seeking both steady earnings and long-term growth.
Liquidity
While REITs are known for their high liquidity due to public trading, fractional investments operate differently. Platforms like Lofty simplify the buying and selling process through digital tools, but liquidity largely depends on platform-specific conditions and market demand. This means transactions might not be as immediate as with publicly traded REITs, but the process is still more streamlined than traditional real estate sales.
sbb-itb-a24235f
Advantages and Disadvantages
When it comes to building a real estate portfolio, both traditional REITs and fractional real estate platforms bring their own perks and challenges. Understanding these differences can help you decide which option aligns better with your financial goals and tolerance for risk.
Traditional REITs stand out for their liquidity and professional management. You can trade shares during regular market hours, just like stocks, which makes them a flexible choice for investors who value quick access to their funds. Additionally, REITs often hold a diverse range of properties, automatically spreading out risk across various markets. However, this broad diversification means you have little say over specific assets, leaving you exposed to potential mismanagement.
Fractional real estate platforms, such as Lofty, offer a hands-on approach to investing. These platforms let you choose specific properties, allowing you to focus on areas or markets that match your insights or risk appetite. Daily rental income provides more frequent cash flow compared to the quarterly dividends typical of REITs. Plus, with fractional real estate, you're investing directly in physical assets rather than owning shares of a management firm.
That said, fractional platforms come with trade-offs. Liquidity is more limited compared to REITs, as selling your stake depends on market demand and platform-specific conditions. While platforms like Lofty simplify transactions, exiting an investment isn’t as seamless as selling REIT shares. Additionally, selecting properties requires more active involvement on your part.
| Feature | Traditional REITs | Fractional Platforms (Lofty) |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | Requires brokerage accounts | Fully digital process |
| Diversification | Automatic exposure to multiple properties | Choose from available properties |
| Risk-Adjusted Returns | Quarterly dividends; professionally managed | Daily rental income |
| Liquidity | High (trades during market hours) | Moderate (depends on platform demand) |
| Control | Minimal control over specific assets | Greater control over property selection |
| Management | Managed by professional REIT teams | Investors directly select properties |
Tax considerations and cost structures vary between these options, so consulting a tax advisor is a smart move to understand the implications for your situation.
If you're looking for a passive income stream with little involvement, traditional REITs provide a straightforward, professionally managed solution. On the other hand, if you enjoy taking an active role in shaping your real estate investments, fractional platforms like Lofty let you pick and invest in properties tailored to your preferences.
Conclusion
Deciding between traditional REITs and fractional real estate platforms comes down to your liquidity needs, level of control, and comfort with risk. Both options offer unique advantages, and understanding these can help you align your investments with your personal goals and market understanding.
If you value easy access to your funds and prefer professional management, traditional REITs might be the better fit. They allow you to trade during market hours and provide exposure to a wide range of properties without requiring hands-on involvement.
On the other hand, fractional platforms like Lofty are ideal for those who want more control over their portfolio. With these platforms, you can invest in specific properties across the U.S., enjoy daily rental income, and avoid the hefty down payments typically associated with real estate. This approach is especially appealing if you’re looking to focus on particular markets or property types.
Your risk tolerance also plays a big role. Conservative investors may lean toward the stability of REITs, while those who enjoy digging into market trends and analyzing individual properties might find fractional ownership more rewarding.
To find the right balance, consider starting with smaller investments in both options. Many seasoned investors combine the two strategies - using REITs for steady, diversified exposure and platforms like Lofty for targeted investments. This mix can enhance portfolio performance while keeping real estate as just one piece of a broader, diversified investment strategy.
FAQs
How can I choose between investing in REITs and fractional real estate based on my financial goals?
Choosing between REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) and fractional real estate platforms comes down to what you’re aiming for financially, how much risk you’re comfortable with, and how hands-on you want to be.
If you value liquidity, diversification, and passive income, REITs might be your go-to. These investments typically deliver annual returns between 6% and 10% and require little to no effort on your part, making them perfect for those who prefer a hands-off approach.
Meanwhile, fractional real estate lets you directly invest in rental properties without needing a massive amount of capital. This option gives you more control over your investments, the chance for higher returns, and the added benefit of property value appreciation. It’s a better fit for those looking for growth and willing to take a more active role in managing their investments.
The right choice depends on your goals, how much risk you’re willing to take, and how involved you want to be in shaping your portfolio.
What are the tax differences between investing in REITs and fractional real estate?
Investing in REITs can lead to dividends being taxed as ordinary income, with rates climbing as high as 37%, plus a potential 3.8% surtax on investment income. That said, REITs do have some tax perks, like avoiding corporate income tax and benefiting from the dividends paid deduction.
In contrast, fractional real estate ownership gives investors access to many of the tax benefits tied to owning property directly. These include deductions for expenses and depreciation. However, it also comes with responsibilities like property taxes, rental income taxes, and other state-specific taxes. To get a clear picture of how these might impact you, it’s a good idea to consult a tax professional.
Can investing in both REITs and fractional real estate improve my portfolio's diversification and returns?
Combining investments in REITs and fractional real estate platforms can add balance and variety to your portfolio. REITs give you access to a wide range of income-producing properties, spreading your risk across different sectors and locations. Meanwhile, fractional real estate investments let you zero in on specific properties that match your financial goals, offering more control and potentially higher returns.
This mix combines the steady nature of REITs with the targeted flexibility of fractional ownership. It can help balance risk and reward while broadening your real estate portfolio. For investors aiming to fine-tune their strategy, this approach offers a practical and strategic way forward.
Related Blog Posts
